Feb 16, 2011

Room

Author: Emma Donoghue
Published: 2010, Little, Brown and Company
336 pages

Jack has lived all five years of his life in "Room" with Ma.  He knows the four walls of Room and all the furniture inside and nothing else.  The only glimpse he gets of the outside world comes from the TV he is allowed to watch for an hour a day, but Ma tells him that most of the things he sees on the TV (other children, ice cream, potato chips) are just pretend.  And sometimes at night, while Jack is hiding in Wardrobe, he gets a whiff of fresh air when Old Nick types in the code that opens Door and enters Room.

When Old Nick is in Room, Ma is not herself, but Jack busies himself by counting the number of times Bed creaks as he lies in Wardrobe.  On the mornings after Old Nick's visits, sometimes Ma has spots on her neck and a hoarse voice, but they go right along with their day as usual.  One day Jack's world is turned upside-down when Ma reveals that she has been lying to him for his whole life, and that the things he sees on TV actually do exist outside of Room.

I don't want to give too much away, because this is a book I feel many of you might actually go out and read yourselves, but I will say that the reason Jack and Ma are in Room is far too dark for innocent Jack to comprehend.  Writing from his perspective, Donoghue has done a great job of keeping the reader in the dark but still intrigued.  If you still aren't convinced, watch this creepy video from Amazon.

Another thing I'll say about this book is that I think the characters are extremely well developed.  Jack's character is a bit contradictory at times, in that sometimes he cannot understand a simple concept or word and other times he is making extremely mature observations and conclusions.  But besides those minor slip-ups, Jack is a good character.  Sometimes he hates Ma, and sometimes he loves her.  He's a good kid, but not too good.  Ma is another one who's totally believable.  She's not a saint -- sometimes she loses her patience with Jack, sometimes she stays in Bed for an entire day -- but she's still likable.  Donoghue proves that characters can have flaws and still be likable, and I wish other authors would follow her lead.

This book won an Alex Award, which doesn't actually mean that much in the literary world, but it's another one of those lists I recommended for finding good books.  I also recommend not reading any of the reviews unless you want to know the ending, which I know most of you will probably do anyway.  One person I know for sure will do this is my own Ma, who, somewhere in a basement, is sitting at a computer and clicking "Add to Cart" on her Amazon account right this minute.  And I also know that as soon as my Ma gets her copy in the mail, she will proceed right to the last page to see how it ends.  So much for keeping it mysterious!

Feb 13, 2011

Thirteen Reasons Why

Author: Jay Asher
Published: 2007, Penguin
288 pages

Clay Jensen receives a shoebox-size package containing seven cassette tapes, numbered 1-13.  When he puts the first one in, he hears the voice of Hannah Baker, his classmate who recently committed suicide.  On the first tape, Hannah makes the chilling statement, "...I'm about to tell you the story of my life.  More specifically, why my life ended.  And if you're listening to these tapes, you're one of the reasons why."

Each person mentioned on the tapes is required to send the package to the next person on the list, until Hannah's story has made it to all the people she blames for her suicide, 13 in all.  The book is written from Clay's point of view, as he follows Hannah's direction on a morbid tour of his town, discovering all the secrets Hannah and his 12 other fellow "reasons" kept from each other.

I have mixed feelings about this book, mostly because I think the two main characters (Hannah and Clay) are one-sided and not totally likable.  Hannah is a dramatic complainer who claims to have been screaming out for help that she just never got.  I knew plenty of people in high school who had it much worse than Hannah, so I found it difficult to feel sorry for her.  Especially when she used her snotty, demeaning tone on the tapes.

Clay, on the other hand, is too perfect.  I'm still not sure why he made it to Hannah's list.  I think the author wanted Clay to be lovable so he gave Clay the most distant connection to Hannah's suicide.  The book would have had much more depth had the narrative been from the point of view of someone who actually played a larger part in Hannah's depression and suicide.  I would have liked to see the softer side of one of those people and be forced to reconcile the soft side with the negative side Hannah reveals on her tapes.

Those problems aside, this is a quick, entertaining read that I would recommend to anybody who shares my taste for morbid, depressing books. If you really want to up the morbidity factor, I recommend going on Jay Asher's website and watching the YouTube videos of the creepy tapes actually being played on a little cassette player.

Last week it went public that this book was picked up by Universal to be made into a movie, with Selena Gomez as Hannah.  I'll definitely be looking forward to that one!