Author: Lauren Oliver
Published: 2010, Harper
470 pages
Yes, another book on this blog that features death as the central theme. I seriously considered becoming a mortician after reading a short story during my freshman English class at Penn State that was actually meant to be horrifying. Everyone else was appropriately horrified, but I went right back to my dorm and started Googling what kind of educational background you need to become a mortician. Turns out, it's not much, and I probably should have pursued it because, unlike libraries, the business of death is, not surprisingly, "Recession-proof."
Enough about my obsession with death, though, and onto the purpose of this blog! Before I Fall was named on YALSA's 2011 Best Fiction for Young Adults List, which is another one of those lists that I won't shut up about. Written from Sam Kingston's first person point of view, the narrative starts out with a normal day in the life of a popular high school girl. She wakes up on February 12, is snotty to her family, puts on a slutty outfit to match her 3 best friends, goes to school and is snotty to everyone there, gets drunk, goes to a party, is snotty again, leaves the party... and that's where it gets interesting.
In the car on the way home, Sam's best friend/drunk driver Lindsay sees a flash of white and swerves into a tree, killing Sam. And then Sam wakes up, and it's February 12 again. For the next 400 pages, Sam has the opportunity to relive her last day seven times, each day discovering something new about the people who are closest to her as well as the people she was always surrounded by but never thought were worth her time.
The biggest complaint most people about this book is that Sam and her friends are not very likable characters. It's definitely true that they're snotty, stuck-up, spoiled little brats who think a little too highly of themselves, but in the end they're not totally evil and they do have many redeeming qualities. I also like that Oliver took the perspective of a "popular girl," which is pretty rare in YA literature, especially in these more serious, non-Gossip Girl books that typically come from the perspective of social outcasts (think Hannah Baker and Melinda Sordino).
In all, the book is entirely too long and the ending is kind of disappointing. There are some interesting questions raised throughout the book, but they're easy to miss among the nearly 500 pages of competing text. Entertaining, yes, but too repetitive for me to recommend. The fact that Lauren Oliver got me to read 500 pages of the same day over and over certainly says something about her writing style, though, so I won't write her off completely.
Showing posts with label death. Show all posts
Showing posts with label death. Show all posts
Jun 4, 2011
Feb 13, 2011
Thirteen Reasons Why
Author: Jay Asher
Published: 2007, Penguin
288 pages
Clay Jensen receives a shoebox-size package containing seven cassette tapes, numbered 1-13. When he puts the first one in, he hears the voice of Hannah Baker, his classmate who recently committed suicide. On the first tape, Hannah makes the chilling statement, "...I'm about to tell you the story of my life. More specifically, why my life ended. And if you're listening to these tapes, you're one of the reasons why."
Each person mentioned on the tapes is required to send the package to the next person on the list, until Hannah's story has made it to all the people she blames for her suicide, 13 in all. The book is written from Clay's point of view, as he follows Hannah's direction on a morbid tour of his town, discovering all the secrets Hannah and his 12 other fellow "reasons" kept from each other.
I have mixed feelings about this book, mostly because I think the two main characters (Hannah and Clay) are one-sided and not totally likable. Hannah is a dramatic complainer who claims to have been screaming out for help that she just never got. I knew plenty of people in high school who had it much worse than Hannah, so I found it difficult to feel sorry for her. Especially when she used her snotty, demeaning tone on the tapes.
Clay, on the other hand, is too perfect. I'm still not sure why he made it to Hannah's list. I think the author wanted Clay to be lovable so he gave Clay the most distant connection to Hannah's suicide. The book would have had much more depth had the narrative been from the point of view of someone who actually played a larger part in Hannah's depression and suicide. I would have liked to see the softer side of one of those people and be forced to reconcile the soft side with the negative side Hannah reveals on her tapes.
Those problems aside, this is a quick, entertaining read that I would recommend to anybody who shares my taste for morbid, depressing books. If you really want to up the morbidity factor, I recommend going on Jay Asher's website and watching the YouTube videos of the creepy tapes actually being played on a little cassette player.
Last week it went public that this book was picked up by Universal to be made into a movie, with Selena Gomez as Hannah. I'll definitely be looking forward to that one!
Published: 2007, Penguin
288 pages
Clay Jensen receives a shoebox-size package containing seven cassette tapes, numbered 1-13. When he puts the first one in, he hears the voice of Hannah Baker, his classmate who recently committed suicide. On the first tape, Hannah makes the chilling statement, "...I'm about to tell you the story of my life. More specifically, why my life ended. And if you're listening to these tapes, you're one of the reasons why."
Each person mentioned on the tapes is required to send the package to the next person on the list, until Hannah's story has made it to all the people she blames for her suicide, 13 in all. The book is written from Clay's point of view, as he follows Hannah's direction on a morbid tour of his town, discovering all the secrets Hannah and his 12 other fellow "reasons" kept from each other.
I have mixed feelings about this book, mostly because I think the two main characters (Hannah and Clay) are one-sided and not totally likable. Hannah is a dramatic complainer who claims to have been screaming out for help that she just never got. I knew plenty of people in high school who had it much worse than Hannah, so I found it difficult to feel sorry for her. Especially when she used her snotty, demeaning tone on the tapes.
Clay, on the other hand, is too perfect. I'm still not sure why he made it to Hannah's list. I think the author wanted Clay to be lovable so he gave Clay the most distant connection to Hannah's suicide. The book would have had much more depth had the narrative been from the point of view of someone who actually played a larger part in Hannah's depression and suicide. I would have liked to see the softer side of one of those people and be forced to reconcile the soft side with the negative side Hannah reveals on her tapes.
Those problems aside, this is a quick, entertaining read that I would recommend to anybody who shares my taste for morbid, depressing books. If you really want to up the morbidity factor, I recommend going on Jay Asher's website and watching the YouTube videos of the creepy tapes actually being played on a little cassette player.
Last week it went public that this book was picked up by Universal to be made into a movie, with Selena Gomez as Hannah. I'll definitely be looking forward to that one!
Jan 5, 2011
If I Stay
Author: Gayle FormanPublished: 2009, Dutton
199 pages
In honor of my cousin Jaclyn, who recently asked for a book recommendation in her Facebook status because apparently I don't give enough positive reviews in this blog, I am doing a week-long series of posts about books that I do recommend. Don't worry, everybody, I have an arsenal of recommendations up my sleeve; I've just been holding back to keep you all on your toes. The time has come, though, and I begin with this sweet, easy read by Gayle Forman.
This book is written from the first-person perspective of 17-year-old Mia. On a snow day, she and her very tight-knit family (Mom, Dad, brother Teddy) decide to take a little road trip that ends in a fatal accident for everyone in the family but Mia. For the majority of the book, Mia is in a coma but her conscious self is wandering around the hospital, watching her remaining family, friends, and doctors and nurses handle the situation.
The narration alternates between stories of Mia's almost-perfect former family life and her current state of watching herself struggle to hold onto life on a hospital bed. At some point, she realizes that she has the power to decide whether she "stays" or dies (hence the title: "If I Stay"). Mia goes back and forth between not wanting to continue living because she doesn't want to be an orphan and also because it is "easier to die" and wanting to continue living because she has so many close loved ones (including an amazing, but still believable, boyfriend as well as a great best friend) and life ahead of her.
Mia's family is quirky and totally lovable and believable. Her parents are former punk rockers who give her a lot of freedom and a lot of love. Her boyfriend is a punk rocker, too, and they have a great (but not too-perfect; they have many real-life relationship conflicts) relationship that I really appreciated. In the stories sprinkled throughout the narrative, Mia describes her perception of her place among all these characters, and the picture Forman paints is both honest and realistic. Mia doesn't feel like she totally fits in because she's a concert cellist and all her loved ones play rock instruments. She's not part of the popular crowd in school, but she's fine having just one really good friend. In the end, she is weighing her options and trying to figure out if she has a place in a world without her immediate family.
Forman raises some interesting questions about life and death, but she also raises some good questions about family. Is your family limited to the one you're born into, or can it also include the people you've chosen to surround yourself with? Who are you without your family? Do you have the same identity if the people who have known you the longest are suddenly gone?
Mia's family reminded me of my own freakishly close family, and maybe that's what I liked about this book so much. I don't know who I'd be without my crazy family, even if they do sometimes insult me by looking elsewhere for book recommendations.
Nov 28, 2010
Looking For Alaska
Author: John Green
Published: 2005, Dutton
221 pages
This is another book that really spoke to my morbid side. It is written from the perspective of Miles, a teenage boy who ships himself off to boarding school in search of "the Great Perhaps" (a quote he borrowed from the last words of poet Francois Rabelais). Once he gets there, he makes a few friends, including his roommate "the Colonel," and falls in love with the girl every other boy is also in love with -- Alaska Young.
The book is organized into two sections: "Before" and "After." Toward the middle of the book, it's still unclear what pivotal event is going to transform the "Before" into the "After." Then Alaska tragically dies. And we have our pivotal event. In the "After" section, Miles and the Colonel commit themselves to uncovering the mystery behind Alaska's death.
This book won the Michael L. Printz Award in 2006, and it is clear why. The characters are extremely well-developed. From timid, naive Miles to destitute, genius the Colonel to smart, strong, moody, feminist Alaska, Green has created completely believable characters. Miles and the Colonel's journey through grief is touching, but it isn't complete over-the-top drama. It maintains a sense of humor and lightheartedness while dealing with such an intense subject matter. The characters and plot, while similar in setting, stand in stark contrast to the one-note characters and stereotypical plot I think Cormier created in The Chocolate War.
My favorite thing about this book is that Miles is obsessed with famous people's last words, and I've decided that I should start getting obsessed with that, too. There are several good last words mentioned in the book, but my favorite are playwright Henrik Ibsen's, on page 11: "...he'd been sick for a while and his nurse said to him, 'You seem to be feeling better this morning,' and Ibsen looked at her and said, 'On the contrary,' and then he died." I don't think it gets much better than that, but if I find any other good ones as I explore my new hobby, I'll let you know.
This is a great book for anyone, but especially for anyone dealing with grief. The message I took away from Miles's journey is that death sucks, but life goes on and the best way to deal with losing someone you love is to celebrate his or her life, not completely bring your own to a halt.
Published: 2005, Dutton
221 pages
This is another book that really spoke to my morbid side. It is written from the perspective of Miles, a teenage boy who ships himself off to boarding school in search of "the Great Perhaps" (a quote he borrowed from the last words of poet Francois Rabelais). Once he gets there, he makes a few friends, including his roommate "the Colonel," and falls in love with the girl every other boy is also in love with -- Alaska Young.
The book is organized into two sections: "Before" and "After." Toward the middle of the book, it's still unclear what pivotal event is going to transform the "Before" into the "After." Then Alaska tragically dies. And we have our pivotal event. In the "After" section, Miles and the Colonel commit themselves to uncovering the mystery behind Alaska's death.
This book won the Michael L. Printz Award in 2006, and it is clear why. The characters are extremely well-developed. From timid, naive Miles to destitute, genius the Colonel to smart, strong, moody, feminist Alaska, Green has created completely believable characters. Miles and the Colonel's journey through grief is touching, but it isn't complete over-the-top drama. It maintains a sense of humor and lightheartedness while dealing with such an intense subject matter. The characters and plot, while similar in setting, stand in stark contrast to the one-note characters and stereotypical plot I think Cormier created in The Chocolate War.
My favorite thing about this book is that Miles is obsessed with famous people's last words, and I've decided that I should start getting obsessed with that, too. There are several good last words mentioned in the book, but my favorite are playwright Henrik Ibsen's, on page 11: "...he'd been sick for a while and his nurse said to him, 'You seem to be feeling better this morning,' and Ibsen looked at her and said, 'On the contrary,' and then he died." I don't think it gets much better than that, but if I find any other good ones as I explore my new hobby, I'll let you know.
This is a great book for anyone, but especially for anyone dealing with grief. The message I took away from Miles's journey is that death sucks, but life goes on and the best way to deal with losing someone you love is to celebrate his or her life, not completely bring your own to a halt.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


