Author: Aimee Bender
Published: Anchor Books, 2010
292 pages
IIIIIIIIIIIIIII'M BAAAAAACKKKK!!! After a long summer of reading way more books than is normal, I am going to start tending to my blog again. I'm going to start with this one because I really want someone else to read it.
This book is written from the perspective of Rose Edelstein, a very average girl with the very above-average ability to taste emotions in food. She discovers her ability rather harshly, after biting into her birthday cake and tasting her mother's contempt, dissatisfaction with her marriage, and overall sadness (hence, the title). Rose continues to experiment with different types of food, and the book moves quickly over the span of about 15 years, during which time Rose never really does anything interesting or noteworthy, except for tasting her mother's affair.
The strangest part about this book is Rose's brother Joseph, who Rose looks up to as a kind of genius. Rose starts to notice he disappears every now and then, and when he reappears he is totally exhausted, and nobody knows why. When he goes away to college, he becomes extremely withdrawn and inaccessible. Then one day, Rose goes to check on him and she walks into his apartment and sees......
Sorry, I can't tell you what she sees because I'm dying for someone else to read this book so they can tell me what the hell they think goes on. Because I still haven't figured it out.
I don't know what it was about this book that made me unable to put it down. It seemed so average and mundane, but I was enthralled. I can't say it any better than the San Francisco Chronicle reviewer who said, "Few writers are as adept as Bender at mingling magical elements so seamlessly with the ordinary." That's exactly what it was. It was a realistic portrait of a slightly strained family with the tiniest fantastical elements that made it a mystery, but still familiar and comfortable.
I am definitely going to see what else Aimee Bender has to offer. Also, first person to read this book and tell me what they think gets a batch of cookies!
Author: Lauren Oliver
Published: 2010, Harper
470 pages
Yes, another book on this blog that features death as the central theme. I seriously considered becoming a mortician after reading a short story during my freshman English class at Penn State that was actually meant to be horrifying. Everyone else was appropriately horrified, but I went right back to my dorm and started Googling what kind of educational background you need to become a mortician. Turns out, it's not much, and I probably should have pursued it because, unlike libraries, the business of death is, not surprisingly, "Recession-proof."
Enough about my obsession with death, though, and onto the purpose of this blog! Before I Fall was named on YALSA's 2011 Best Fiction for Young Adults List, which is another one of those lists that I won't shut up about. Written from Sam Kingston's first person point of view, the narrative starts out with a normal day in the life of a popular high school girl. She wakes up on February 12, is snotty to her family, puts on a slutty outfit to match her 3 best friends, goes to school and is snotty to everyone there, gets drunk, goes to a party, is snotty again, leaves the party... and that's where it gets interesting.
In the car on the way home, Sam's best friend/drunk driver Lindsay sees a flash of white and swerves into a tree, killing Sam. And then Sam wakes up, and it's February 12 again. For the next 400 pages, Sam has the opportunity to relive her last day seven times, each day discovering something new about the people who are closest to her as well as the people she was always surrounded by but never thought were worth her time.
The biggest complaint most people about this book is that Sam and her friends are not very likable characters. It's definitely true that they're snotty, stuck-up, spoiled little brats who think a little too highly of themselves, but in the end they're not totally evil and they do have many redeeming qualities. I also like that Oliver took the perspective of a "popular girl," which is pretty rare in YA literature, especially in these more serious, non-Gossip Girl books that typically come from the perspective of social outcasts (think Hannah Baker and Melinda Sordino).
In all, the book is entirely too long and the ending is kind of disappointing. There are some interesting questions raised throughout the book, but they're easy to miss among the nearly 500 pages of competing text. Entertaining, yes, but too repetitive for me to recommend. The fact that Lauren Oliver got me to read 500 pages of the same day over and over certainly says something about her writing style, though, so I won't write her off completely.
Author: Philip Pullman
Published: 1996, Knopf
399 pages
Philip Pullman is a genius. I could talk about this book for days, but I'll try to reel it in as best I can. This is Book #1 in a trilogy, and probably the only one I'll talk about unless I get requests to post about the others. The other two are The Subtle Knife, and The Amber Spyglass. The truth is, there are so many underlying themes in all of these books that can go right over children's heads, but there is also a fantastic story that everyone can enjoy.
The story follows the child Lyra Belacqua, who is easily my favorite character ever created, as she travels to the North to save her friend and other children who have been captured to endure horrendous experiments at the hands of the Magisterium. Pullman has created a truly magical world in which polar bears can talk, witches fly through the Northern sky, and all humans have animal counterparts called daemons.
In the midst of Lyra's adventure, Pullman manages to skillfully intertwine elements of modern science, my favorite being the Many-Worlds Theory of quantum physics. If you're interested in that aspect, an entire book has been written about that alone: The Science of Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials.
There has been a lot of controversy about this book, especially when it was being made into a movie in 2007, that stems mostly from Pullman's outspoken atheism. There are certainly some elements in The Golden Compass that are anti-organized religion, but this theme is not as prevalent in the first book as it is in the second two (and definitely not as prevalent as it is in his latest book: The Good Man Jesus and The Scoundrel Christ). And, frankly, the story is good enough that if you didn't know anything about the controversy before reading it, you might completely miss it.
Anyway, I'm glad I'm so obsessed with this book because now I can name my future spawn Lyra instead of "Ponyboy Curtis," which I was planning to do after reading The Outsiders and which is just not a socially acceptable name (no, not even for a librarian's child). My future child thanks you, Philip Pullman.
Author: Jane Yolen
Published: 1992, Tor Books
241 pages
After finishing (and being very disappointed in) Zel, I started rethinking my decision to read Briar Rose, another reimagined fairy tale. Fortunately, I decided to stick it out… And I couldn’t be happier with my decision! In case any of you don’t know (I didn’t until I read this book), “Briar Rose” is another name for “Sleeping Beauty.”
To me, Briar Rose represents everything a reimagined fairy tale should be. The story is new while still being recognizable. Yolen takes the familiar Sleeping Beauty fairy tale and turns it into a Holocaust mystery. We follow Becca, our main character, along on her journey to discover where her mysterious Grandmother came from and why she always claimed to be Briar Rose.
I’ve done a lot of Holocaust reading — fiction and non-fiction — but I’ve never read a Holocaust mystery. “Historical Holocaust fiction” and “fairy tale mystery” are two concepts I would never expect to be a fitting description of a single book, but Yolen manages to pull it off without losing any of the horror of the Holocaust nor the fantasy of a fairy tale.
If you’re interested in Holocaust fiction or nonfiction (I know I am… very morbid, I know. I’ll also read anything about the death penalty. I swear I’m not maintaining this blog from inside a psych ward.) then this is a good book to add to your shelf.
Author: Donna Jo Napoli
Published: 1996, Dutton Books
240 pages
Zel is Napoli’s reimagining of the classic Rapunzel fairy tale. I seem to be the only person who didn’t enjoy this book. I have nothing against fairy tale retellings, but I do not think Napoli offers anything fresh or unique to the classic fairy tale, except for giving us more background information and painstakingly (emphasis on the pain) more detail.
Napoli goes in-depth about what it was like for Rapunzel to be locked up in the tower. Rapunzel eventually goes mad (as would be expected from someone who is locked in isolation for years), and the imagery along the way is absolutely horrifying. I appreciate that Napoli tries to give us a bit of realism, but for me it was just too much.
Napoli attempts to bring the tale down to earth, and what we end up with is something so grounded that it is a total bore. It’s nice to see Rapunzel and the prince having actual emotions and fears and faults (as opposed to their stereotypical fairy tale counterparts), but at no point in the book do any of their emotions or fears or faults actually surprise me. It is exactly what I would have expected from the original fairy tale version, just 240 pages longer.
I am going to stop calling this a “reimagined” fairy tale and call it just an “extended” fairy tale. Maybe that will make it more tolerable for me.